Our Civil Service System is One of the Foundations of Good Government and Whistleblower Rights — It is Being Threatened with Extinction
Whistleblowing Matters: A Newsletter from Mehri & Skalet, PLLC – FindJustice.com
By: Richard Condit and Cleveland Lawrence III
In a single month, the guardrails meant to keep the federal workforce independent of political control have taken two direct hits.
First, the Supreme Court’s 6-3 decision in Trump v. Slaughter overruled Humphrey’s Executor v. United States — a 91-year-old precedent — and held that the President may remove virtually all commissioners of multi-member independent federal agencies at will.
Next, Office of Personnel Management’s (OPM) Merit Hiring Plan began requiring job applicants to honor presidential loyalty. Meanwhile, a proposed government-wide NDA threatens federal employees, and just this week, Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth escalated the stakes by announcing a joint DOJ task force to identify and prosecute government workers who leak sensitive information to journalists.
We have seen what happens if we are not careful: whenever the guarantees that empower civil servants act independently — tenure protections, a neutral adjudicator, freedom from loyalty tests — have come under pressure, whistleblower disclosures have been the first casualty and the public has paid the price.
At Mehri & Skalet we are actively advising clients to protect their rights. Our firm has a long history of fighting for whistleblowers and exposing wrongdoing. And we are ready to take on new clients who are facing retaliation or considering making a disclosure in this environment.
THE SYSTEM AMERICA ORIGINALLY BUILT — AND WHY IT MATTERS
In 1881, a disgruntled office-seeker who believed he was owed a federal job for his political loyalty assassinated President James Garfield. Congress’s response — the Pendleton Civil Service Reform Act of 1883 — established merit-based hiring through competitive examination and prohibited conditioning employment on political contributions. The lesson: a spoils system does not just corrupt government; it can get a president killed.
The modern framework was completed by the Civil Service Reform Act of 1978 (CSRA), enacted in the aftermath of the Watergate scandal and championed by President Jimmy Carter. The CSRA created the Merit Systems Protection Board (MSPB) and codified the first statutory protections against retaliation for federal employee whistleblowers — protections later strengthened by the Whistleblower Protection Act of 1989 (WPA). In 2012, the law was further amended and improved by the passage of the Whistleblower Protection Enhancement Act (WPEA).
For 143 years, this system resisted efforts by both parties to revive the spoils system, delivering enormous value. For example, NIH’s research programs drove foundational advances in cancer, HIV/AIDS, and genomics; VA researchers co-developed the first implantable cardiac pacemaker; the DoD’s GPS program, opened to full civilian precision use in 2000, transformed navigation globally; EPA enforcement of the Clean Air Act reduced aggregate air pollution by 78% while the economy grew 285%; and CDC vaccination programs have prevented an estimated 1.1 million deaths and 508 million illnesses over the past three decades.
Those achievements were possible because civil servants had job security and the institutional independence to do their jobs — not to please their political supervisors. And when those supervisors acted wrongfully, the same system provided at least some protections for civil servants who spoke up.
WHAT HAPPENS WHEN CIVIL SERVANTS BLOW THE WHISTLE
History has demonstrated that meaningful whistleblower protections are the difference between accountability and cover-up. Time and again, it has been whistleblowers’ courage that exposed wrongdoing and reshaped history:
- Army Corps contracting officer Bunnatine Greenhouse (2005) called out a $7 billion no-bid Halliburton contract as the “most blatant and improper contract abuse” of her career, resulting in $553 million in disallowed payments and procurement reforms enacted by Congress.
- Marine Corps civilian Franz Gayl (2007) documented a 19-month Pentagon delay in fielding battlefield vehicles when improvised explosive devices caused 60% of U.S. combat deaths in Iraq. Then-Secretary of Defense, Robert Gates, credited accelerated deployment with saving “thousands and thousands of lives.”
- Federal Air Marshal Robert MacLean (2003–2015) disclosed that TSA was pulling air marshals from flights during an active hijacking alert. A 7-2 Supreme Court ruling in DHS v. MacLean, 574 U.S. 383 (2015), held that agency regulations cannot strip WPA coverage — strengthening protections government-wide.
- Retired VA physician Dr. Sam Foote (2014) exposed the Phoenix VA’s secret waiting lists — at least 40 veterans died while awaiting care — triggering nationwide Inspector General investigations that found 57,000 veterans waiting over 90 days for appointments, and leading directly to the Veterans Access, Choice and Accountability Act of 2014.
- An anonymous intelligence community employee (2019) filed a complaint under the Intelligence Community Whistleblower Protection Act of 1988, reporting presidential pressure on Ukraine. Transmitted to Congress over executive branch resistance, the complaint became the basis for Trump’s first impeachment and prompted new House rules protecting whistleblower identities.
- BARDA Director Dr. Rick Bright (2020) was removed after warning of COVID-19 unpreparedness and opposing premature promotion of hydroxychloroquine (HCQ) as a treatment. The Office of Special Counsel (OSC) found “reasonable grounds to believe” that HHS unlawfully retaliated against Bright in violation of the WPA; his case settled.
Our whistleblower team has represented federal employees in retaliation matters throughout different agencies — from nuclear safety workers who raised contamination and safety concerns at the Hanford site, to more recently representing technologists who were terminated when DOGE dismantled 18F, the GSA’s digital services unit built to make government technology work for the public.
These disclosures were possible because the whistleblowers had civil service protections, an independent MSPB, and access to the OSC. Each of those safeguards is now seriously compromised.
AN YEAR AND A HALF ONSLAUGHT
Since January 2025, the Trump administration and the Supreme Court have together imposed the most sweeping restructuring of the federal civil service since the Pendleton Act — in every case at the expense of independence and protections for civil servants.
- January 2025 — DOGE and the Mass Dismantling of the Federal Workforce. OPM emailed all 2.3 million federal employees a “Fork in the Road” buyout — resign now, get paid through September. About 150,000 took the deal. By year’s end, over 260,000 workers had left federal service.
- February 2025 — After the President fired MSPB Chair Cathy Harris, a quorum crisis left thousands of federal employees with no path to court for months. The administration then argued that DOJ’s own lawyers bind the board’s rulings, making the board formally subordinate to the executive branch.
- December 2025 — OPM’s Merit Hiring Plan is intended, in part, to prevent the hiring of employees who will not faithfully serve the Executive Branch. There are optional questions in some job application materials that applicants can answer to explain how they’ll “advance the president’s executive orders.”
- June 2026 — Schedule Policy/Career strips CSRA protections from ~8,000 (soon 50,000) reclassified employees, routing their whistleblower complaints to their own agencies’ counsel.
- June 2026 — In a 6-3 decision, the Supreme Court overruled Humphrey’s Executor v. United States, 295 U.S. 602 (1935), holding that Congress may not restrict the President’s power to fire commissioners of most multi-member independent agencies — including the MSPB. Justice Sotomayor warned the ruling “distorts the structure of Government to fit the majority’s theory of unitary, total executive control.”
- June 2026 — A proposed government-wide NDA (91 FR 31478) defines “pre-decisional or deliberative material” broadly enough to chill protected disclosures. Refuse to sign, and you’re barred from federal employment for five years. Know your rights before you sign.
HOW WE FIGHT
Unless Congress creates an Article I court with genuine independence or amends the CSRA to permit direct federal court access, federal employees seeking to vindicate whistleblower retaliation claims face a corrupted adjudicatory system — and the public loses the accountability those claims produce.
To federal employees considering blowing the whistle: DON’T GO IT ALONE. The legal landscape is complex, and how, when, and to whom you disclose can determine whether your protections hold up. Mehri & Skalet has defended federal whistleblowers before, and we’re ready to do it again.
If you’re facing an imminent threat to workplace safety, public health, or the environment, time matters. Consider making an anonymous disclosure to the appropriate Office of Inspector General — and reach out to our team at Mehri & Skalet.